The Case for Covenantal Infant Baptism

Among Christians, and especially Christians of the Reformed stripe, few issues are as hotly debated as baptism. Much ink (not to mention much blood) has been spilled over the proper understanding of this sacrament. With so much debate and so many resources it can be incredibly difficult to decide what to read about this important issue. In my own quest to understand baptism I picked up The Case for Covenantal Infant Baptism edited by Gregg Strawbridge.

In this work Strawbridge compiled essays from sixteen influential paedobaptist writers (many of whom are presidents at reformed seminaries) such as Bryan Chapell, Daniel Doriani, Richard Pratt, and Cornelius Venema. The book is divided into fifteen chapters with each writer covering a different aspect of the case for paedobaptism.

Herein lies this books strengths and weaknesses. The unique format of the book allows the reader to see the paedobaptist argument in different ways. For example: Bryan Chapell gives a pastoral introduction to infant baptism while Jeffrey D. Niell, Richard L. Pratt, Cornelius Venema, and Randy Booth argue from the basis of the covenant. Lyle Bierma and Peter Leithart argue from church history, and Mark Ross explains the idea of baptism as a sign and seal. As you've probably picked up, these authors are able to cover a lot of territory because of the format. However, this approach also has its weaknesses. Because of the layout there isn't as much time to develop any one argument or approach. It might also make things disorienting for someone new to the debate. Although all the authors bring tremendous gifts to this work the varied nature of the writing serves as both a strength and a weakness.

In the end, I think The Case for Covenantal Infant Baptism is a worthwhile investment. Strawbridge's brief introduction alone provides a clear presentation of the issues from a biblical perspective. The authors unite in making a passionate and scholarly (yet movingly pastoral) argument for paedobaptism. If you're looking for a good book to add to your library on the topic of baptism, this would be a good choice.